Child A
The prosecution’s theory: Air embolism injected intravenously.
Outcome: Died 8 June 2015
Gestation: Twin 2, male; 31+2 weeks, 1.66 kg
Sensitivity note: court-imposed lifelong anonymity covers every family. We use the court-assigned code only. See our families and witnesses sensitivity policy.
Prosecution theory
Air embolism injected intravenously.
Method alleged: Injection of air into an IV line causing fatal venous air embolism.
Prosecution experts: Dr Dewi Evans (lead); Dr Sandie Bohin. Both cited the Lee & Tanswell 1989 paper.
Panel view (Feb 2025)
Panel: died from thrombosis. No evidence of air embolism.
Pathology
Panel conclusion: Baby 1 died from thrombosis; there was no evidence of air embolism. The mother had anti-phospholipid syndrome (not charted in the medical records), which can pass antibodies across the placenta and predispose the newborn to thromboembolism. The post-mortem showed a recent non-occluding thrombus in the liver, indicating a recent thrombotic event. On the day of the collapse two central catheters were left without infusion for up to four hours — which predisposes to thrombosis — and the collapse came shortly after infusion restarted in the most central line. The Panel's reading is that a thrombus from the catheter tip likely migrated to an artery supplying the brain stem, causing sudden collapse and inability to resuscitate. On the skin discolouration relied on at trial, Zhou and Lee (Am J Perinatol, Dec 2024) found patchy skin discolouration has never been reported in infants with venous air embolism.
Natural-cause alternatives identified
- Thrombosis — the Panel's stated cause of death
- Maternal anti-phospholipid syndrome predisposing the infant to thromboembolism
- Catheter-associated thrombus (two central lines left without infusion for up to four hours)
- Placental fetal vascular malperfusion
What the jury did not hear
- The Panel's conclusion that Baby 1 died from thrombosis, with no evidence of air embolism.
- That the mother's anti-phospholipid syndrome was not charted in the medical records.
- The significance of the recent non-occluding liver thrombus found at post-mortem.
- Zhou and Lee (Am J Perinatol, December 2024): patchy skin discolouration has never been reported in infants with venous air embolism.
Key primary sources
- International Expert Panel — Summary Report (February 2025), Panel Baby 1: https://lucyletbyinnocence.com/shoo-lee/International%20Expert%20Panel%20-%20Summary%20Report.pdf
- R v Letby sentencing remarks (August 2023), Mr Justice Goss
- Lee & Tanswell (1989) Arch Dis Child
Read the full long-form analysis →
Sources:
- Court of Appeal judgment (May 2024) and sentencing remarks — judiciary.uk
- Shoo Lee International Expert Panel Report (February 2025) — lucyletbyinnocence.com
- Per-baby trial evidence archive — lucyletbyinnocence.com
This page uses only the court-assigned code and publicly reported facts. The court imposed lifelong anonymity on every family; this site does not contact families and does not speculate about private circumstances.